October 4, 2024 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

Pepperdine Title IX loss may expand LGBT protections

Hayley Videckis and Layana White
Hayley Videckis and Layana White

BY STAFF  |  In what is likely to be a first step toward an expansion of Title IX, the law that prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in federally funded education programs, United States District Judge Dean D. Pregerson ruled that a sexual orientation discrimination case brought against Pepperdine University may move forward in court.

In Videckis v. Pepperdine University, two former women’s basketball players maintain their coach and University staff members “harassed and discriminated” against them in an effort to force them to quit the team after discovering they were a lesbian couple.

Layana White and Haley Videckis, claim “the university violated their privacy as well as Title IX of the U.S. Civil Rights Act.”

Pepperdine argued “Title IX did not cover claims based on sexual orientation discrimination,” according to court documents.  Pepperdine argued that because the women’s relationship was not known to them the claim of discrimination or retaliation based on sexual orientation was moot.  The judge rejected the logic: “In sexual orientation discrimination cases, focusing on the actions or appearance of the alleged victim of discrimination rather than the bias of the alleged perpetrator asks the wrong question and compounds the harm.  A plaintiff’s ‘actual’ sexual orientation is irrelevant to a Title IX or Title VII claim because it is the biased mind of the alleged discriminator that is the focus of the analysis.  This is especially true given that sexuality cannot be defined on a homosexual or heterosexual basis; it exists on a continuum.  It is not the victim of discrimination who should be forced to put his or her sexual orientation on trial.  We do not demand of a victim of alleged religious discrimination, ‘Prove that you are a real Catholic, Mormon, or Jew.’  Just as it would be absurd to demand that a victim of alleged racial discrimination prove that he is black, it is absurd to demand a victim of alleged sex discrimination based on sexual orientation prove she is a lesbian.  The contrary view would turn a Title IX trial into a broad inquisition into the personal sexual history of the victim.  Such an approach should be precluded as not only highly inflammatory and offensive, but also irrelevant for the purposes of the Title IX discrimination analysis.”

Judge Pregerson ruled that sexual-orientation discrimination is sex discrimination: “Here, Plaintiffs allege that they were told that ‘lesbianism’ would not be tolerated on the team. If Plaintiffs had been males dating females, instead of females dating females, they would not have been subjected to the alleged different treatment. Plaintiffs have stated a straightforward claim of sex discrimination under Title IX.”

The judge says his ruling aligns with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission decision that maintains sexual orientation is discrimination under Title VII, which prevents sex discrimination in the workforce.

Aligning Title VII and Title IX rulings is “a crucial part of the case,” making for a “proper ruling,” said a spokesperson for Lambda Legal.

The lawyer for Videckis and White, Jeremy Gray say that “a simple way to consider the issue of whether the word ‘sex’ in Title IX applies to our clients’ claims, is to ask a straightforward question. If we were to change the gender (sex) of one of our clients would there have ever been an issue with their relationship? Of course not. By definition, the sex of our clients was an essential component of the discrimination — and Title IX applies here.”

Pepperdine University Public Relations Office:  “The court’s broad interpretation of Title IX and its application to this specific case is surprising.

Pepperdine always strives to act in the best interests of its students and the teams on which they play.  A thorough and comprehensive investigation confirmed this and found no evidence to support the plaintiffs’ allegations. The University anticipates that the court will reach the same conclusion.

Our University remains committed to a diverse and inclusive environment.”

in LEGAL
Related Posts

LA County Addresses Disproportionate Amount Of Women and LGBTQ Populations In L.A. Jails

November 16, 2021

November 16, 2021

On Tuesday, October 19, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors passed a motion that the board hopes will do...

Local Leaders Celebrate Supreme Court LGBT Discrimination Ban

June 16, 2020

June 16, 2020

Supreme Court votes 6-3 in case Bostock v. Clayon County, Georgia By Sam Catanzaro Los Angeles-area leaders are celebrating the...

Honoring Timothy Dean One Year Later

January 8, 2020

January 8, 2020

An intimate gathering was held Tuesday, Jan. 7 at West Hollywood Park to honor the 1-year anniversary of 55-year-old fashion...

Open Letter to FB Demands Removal of “Factually Inaccurate” Lawsuit Ads Attacking HIV Medication

December 14, 2019

December 14, 2019

Dozens of LGBTQ+, HIV and public health organizations have signed an open letter calling on Facebook to remove law firm...

California One of Top States in Equality CA’s Legislative Scorecard

December 5, 2019

December 5, 2019

California earned top marks in Equality California’s recently released annual state legislative scorecard for 2019 Equality California, the nation’s largest statewide...

Trump Administration Attacks LGBTQ People Yet Again with HHS Proposed Rule

November 4, 2019

November 4, 2019

To kick off Trans Awareness Month, the Trump Administration has outdone itself in trampling over LGBTQ+ folks’ rights. Today, the...

PrEP Now Available Without Prescription in CA

October 14, 2019

October 14, 2019

Access to HIV prevention medications got a little easier. Last week, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a bill that would allow...

Ed Buck Arrested After Third Alleged Meth OD Victim Survives, Calls 911

September 18, 2019

September 18, 2019

LGBTQ political activist and prominent donor to the Democratic Party Ed Buck was arrested Tuesday, September 17 after a third alleged victim...

CA Senate Bills You Need to Know About

August 8, 2019

August 8, 2019

SB 201, 159 and 233 all aim to make a change for LGBTQ+ members — find out who they aim...

Policy Brief Outlines How Trump’s New Healthcare Plan Would Harm LGBTQ+ Community

August 8, 2019

August 8, 2019

The Fenway Institute of Fenway Health recently released a policy brief outlining the harm to LGBTQ+ people likely to result...

Gov. Newsom Signs LBQ Women’s Equity Fund

July 11, 2019

July 11, 2019

By Jorge Paniagua It took months, but advocates a part of the Los Angeles LGBT Center are celebrating a substantial...

BREAKING: House Passes Equality Act LGBTQ rights Bill

May 17, 2019

May 17, 2019

Despite previously aggressive pushback from Republican lawmakers, the US House of Representatives passed the Equality Act on Friday, May 17....

Intersex Rights Bill Tabled Until Next Year

April 24, 2019

April 24, 2019

A state bill designed to provide intersex individuals with informed consent for medical treatments regarding their sex characteristics has been...

LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Defending the Rainbow Flag Creator

April 13, 2019

April 13, 2019

In response to a “Letter to the Editor” regarding the true identity for the historic rainbow flag creator My name...

The Owner of Two Luxury L.A. Hotels is the Sultan of a Country that Now Stones Homosexuals to Death

April 3, 2019

April 3, 2019

Brunei implemented Sharia Law this week, making sodomy and adultery punishable by death. Strict homophobic Islamic laws went into effect...