January 19, 2020 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

OP/ED: On the American Mythology of Guns

By SAMUEL BRASLOW| This is how the argument goes, as summed up by one writer for the conservative site Daily Wire: “We Americans don’t want to keep our guns so we can overthrow the government; we want to keep our guns so we never have to.”

I’ve heard this argument floated around for years, but it came to a head when I heard an acquaintance make it in the wake of the Douglas High shooting. Sure, he admitted, one person can inflict staggering damage with one gun—but imagine what an entire government can do when it’s people don’t have any. He pointed to Nazi Germany, the USSR, and North Korea. Had there been more guns and less gun control, then the citizens of each country would have resisted the oppressive regimes.

I didn’t know how to respond at the time.

Seventeen people are dead—shot at a school. Before that, there were 4 killed at a car wash. A little further, 5 murdered at another school—an elementary school that time. Before that, 26 at a church service. Then there were 58 at a concert. And then 5 at an office. And 4 at a bank. And another 4 at a club. And 5 again at an airport. And that’s only the last year.

Did you have the patience to read through that whole list? Because I hardly have the patience—the emotional stamina—to care each time it happens again and again and again. Especially since Sandy Hook came and went without any change, I’ve become increasingly fatalistic on the subject. But with politicians completely hamstrung to do anything, it seems as if the best thing we can do is challenge the mythology that props up our gun-obsessed culture.

Let’s talk about the facts. The overwhelming consensus among historians and experts dismisses the argument that gun control played a causal role in authoritarianism. Dictators do not boil down to the absence or presence of guns. If we did follow that logic, we should make all military instruments available to the civilian population as a check on the government. I mean, anything short of leasable tanks and any resistance would be like holding out a sheet of paper to block a bayonet. You could probably mount a decent guerrilla campaign for a bit, but without control of manufacturing centers, it’d end up like the Spanish Civil War (an instance in which guns were not enough to stop a fascist dictator).

But that gets away from an even bigger point. What are we supposed to make of every other wealthy country on Earth? Is Japan inching closer to totalitarianism? Is Britain ripe for a military coup? Is Justin Trudeau plotting to install himself as President for Life? Guns are not what keep us safe from power-hungry despots. Impartial courts, checks and balances, dogged journalists, and informed and active citizens keep us safe.

Nina Simone once described freedom as the absence of fear. You know what I thought about when I saw Black Panther on Friday, sitting in the theater and waiting for the movie to start? Aurora. You know what I thought about when I went out afterwards? Pulse. And you know what I’ll think about now when I drive by my alma mater, North Hollywood High School? Douglas High. So no, I have no stomach for hypothetical future-tense tyranny when we already live under a very real tyranny right now.

Related Posts

COLUMN: “The L Word: Generation Q” is a Pandering Mess

December 11, 2019

December 11, 2019

It’s strange to look back across a period of ten years and realize how much you’ve changed. Things that felt...

DEAR AIDAN: Bro Wants to Downplay My Relationship with My Husband?

November 26, 2019

November 26, 2019

Dear Aidan! The Holiday season is coming up and I am going to be going back to my hometown for...

DEAR AIDAN: My Ex-Boyfriend’s Current Boyfriend Hates Me!

November 1, 2019

November 1, 2019

Dear Aidan: I am friends with my ex boyfriend, like pretty close to him. Unfortunately it seems that his new...

HUMAN SPOTLIGHT: NiK Kacy Breaks the Binary

October 29, 2019

October 29, 2019

How I’m breaking the binary and building my own LGBTQ-owned business  Column By NiK Kacy  Living with intersectional and multi-cultural...

COLUMN: 5 Things We’re Excited About For Dark Harbor’s LGBTQ+ Night at Queen Mary

October 24, 2019

October 24, 2019

With Halloween only a week away, folks are scrambling to squeeze in as much spooky fun as possible. The Queen...

DEAR AIDAN: Feeling Uninspired By My Own Ambition

October 14, 2019

October 14, 2019

Dear Aidan,  Currently I am in a dead end, low paying job that I am very unhappy at. I want...

COLUMN: When Same-sex Parents Divorce, Who Gets Custody of Frozen Embryos?

October 9, 2019

October 9, 2019

By Debra R. Schoenberg, Esq.  The miracles of modern medicine can offer the gift of life to many same-sex couples...

DEAR AIDAN: Feeling Idle in Los Angeles

October 3, 2019

October 3, 2019

Dear Aidan, I know it seems like a stupid simple problem but I just moved to Los Angeles area and...

COLUMN: How to Safely Prep to Bottom

August 22, 2019

August 22, 2019

By Dr. Evan Goldstein, founder of Future Method When it comes to sex, the majority of gay men don’t have access...

DEAR AIDAN: Disclosing HIV Positive Status?

July 25, 2019

July 25, 2019

Dear Aidan: I am HIV Positive and am jumping into the dating world. I know that there is a stigma...

COLUMN: L.A. in the Ranking of American Cities for LGBTQ+ Dating

July 24, 2019

July 24, 2019

By David Cusick Across the US, the LGBTQ+ community is becoming more widely accepted each day and each year. Still,...

DEAR AIDAN: Why Doesn’t He Like Me?

July 15, 2019

July 15, 2019

Dear Aidan, I have a person that I see often in the community who is always out to get me....

DEAR AIDAN: How to Avoid Ex at L.A. Pride

June 4, 2019

June 4, 2019

Dear Aidan, I am going to a Pride party this weekend! Unfortunately I recently had an ugly breakup last week...

IN THE COMMUNITY: UCLA Lambda LGBTQ Alumni Association’s Gala Brunch

May 20, 2019

May 20, 2019

On Sunday, April 28th with over 100 attendees registered, the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) Lambda LGBTQ Alumni Association...