“Religious Freedom” laws grow more onerous and go viral

By
Troy Masters
-
Religious Freedom bills are spreading nationwide.
Religious Freedom bills are spreading nationwide.
Religious Freedom bills are spreading nationwide and they’re meaner than ever.

BY TROY MASTERS  |  Almost in a blink of the eye since the Supreme Court of the United States made same-sex marriages legal nationwide, Religious Freedom bills have been debated or implemented across the country in whack-a-mole fashion.

- Advertisement -

Even before last June’s ruling, LGBT rights groups had been putting out Religious Freedom bill fires across the nation— successfully in some places. But recently we have seen them grow in scope, going as far as preventing local municipalities from enacting laws that protect LGBT people and crafting an outright license to discriminate.

There’s no real mystery about the political strategy of the “Religious Freedom Restoration Act.” The bills seek to strengthen the legal argument in the Hobby Lobby case that allows one person to discriminate against another citing their “sincerely held religious belief” as their reason. That case gave employers a wide path to discrimination and even allows them to withhold employment based insurance coverage of medical procedures they deem in conflict with the owners personal faith. That is why LGBT rights groups, along with a slew of corporations and celebrities, have protested the bills and laws as they have arisen.

Just this week an antigay Religious Freedom bill was vetoed by the Governor of Georgia but another in North Carolina that also prohibits local municipalities from enacting pro-LGBT ordinances has so far persevered.

On Tuesday, April 5, Republican Mississippi Gov. Phil Bryant signed into law what is widely believed to be the most sweeping anti-LGBT legislation in the U.S., granting denial of products and services in a wide range of venues. The bill passed 70-47 in the Republican-controlled state House of Representatives, despite several procedural attempts to kill or delay the bill by Democrats. Bryant said he signed the bill “to protect the sincerely held religious beliefs and moral convictions of of individuals, organizations, and private associations.”

In a fuck you move, Mississippi’s state’s Religious Freedom bill was signed into law days after the Supreme Court of the United States ruled Mississippi’s ban against child-adoption by same-sex couples was unconstitutional.

Most Democrats were furious. “This is the most hateful bill I have seen in my career in the legislature,” said Rep. Stephen Holland, telling his Republican colleagues, “You ought to be ashamed of yourself.”

What are these laws? Why do we fear them? What do they do? What is their history? The original impetus for Religious Freedom laws is worth a look to provide a wider context for such targeted discrimination.

Originally, the idea for “religious freedom” laws had no connection to same-sex marriage or gay rights.  In the early 1960s, the Supreme Court took on a case called Sherbet v. Verner and with it established a basic standard for protecting the free exercise of religion. The government could pass laws that impacted free exercise if it was possible to demonstrate a “compelling interest.” An example of such a compelling interest might be protecting public safety — or, following enactment of civil rights laws, preventing discrimination based on race.

But a series of rulings during the early 1990s drew outrage when the federal courts allowed the government to infringe upon Native American religious practices — in part by withholding unemployment benefits from people who used peyote. The Court reasoned such laws were ok because they did not single out specific religions — even though the ruling effectively impeded the practice of certain faiths. Congress responded to the infringement by passing a federal Religious Freedom law. The Senate vote was overwhelming and bipartisan (97-to-3) and was signed by President Bill Clinton.

The federal religious freedom law said the government may not “substantially burden” the practice of religion without a “compelling interest.” And even if the government does have such an interest, the law said, it must shield the interest in the “least restrictive” way. The Supreme Court clarified that religious freedom law could apply only to federal action and that lead some state legislatures to pass their own laws. Most state constitutions already provided residents with similar guarantees.

Fast forward through 20 years of silence on the matter. In 2014, the Supreme Court ruled in the Hobby Lobby case that corporations could essentially act as people and create discriminatory rules if the corporate owners had “sincerely held religious beliefs.” (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/27/magazine/what-the-hobby-lobby-ruling-means-for-america.html).

That gave religious conservatives the impetus to morph the ruling over Obamacare and contraception coverage into a backlash over the rapid legal advances and social acceptance of LGBT people. In states without gay rights laws on the books, last June’s Supreme Court ruling requiring each state to honor same-sex marriages provided impetus to conservatives to use religious freedom laws to construct what they hope will be a gay rights firewall.

WE ARE NOW TALKING ABOUT AS MANY AS 36 PROBLEM STATES
Most of us fear these laws are a cudgel that allow willy-nilly discrimination against LGBT people. Some say the laws give cover to people of faith to practice aspects of their religion that heretofore have been have kept in check by civil rights laws, such as denying public services and accommodations.  Others say the laws are a poorly constructed — but necessary – intersectional negotiation of the freedom of religion and the mandates of civil law. For LGBT and allied civil rights advocates, recent events in North Carolina and Mississippi show that newer executions of so-called religious liberty laws are more onerous and broaden challenges to non-traditional gender pairings, mores and identity.

Religious freedoms laws have grown beyond the question of faith and have moved into the realm of individual personal discomfort (such as the basic right to pee) and one’s right to express anger over that discomfort, thus denying basic civil rights. The laws have evolved to give businesses and business owners broad leeway to pick and choose which customers they will serve, which employees to hire or fire, etc. Worst yet, in states where the laws were passed as so-called anti-transgender “ bathroom bill,” any individual can now act as the “genital police” and challenge someone going into a bathroom to prove that they match the gender assigned to that bathroom. The bills essentially criminalize peeing, based solely on one individual’s perception of another individual’s personal appearance. A straight “butch-looking” woman with short cropped hair could be challenged upon entering the “Ladies Room” if someone perceives her to be a guy in disguise.

Religious freedom laws and LGBT rights are now on an inexorable collision course.

Because there is no federal overarching LGBT civil rights bill that would prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity, LGBT people must rely on a patchwork of state and local laws.  This is why LGBT and allied civil rights advocates are pushing for the Equality Act, which has been introduced in Congress but is not expected to even get a hearing under current Republican-control.

TARGETING “COMPELLING INTERESTS” 
Meanwhile, Mississippi and North Carolina’s new laws give business owners protection they didn’t have before. And by going the extra step of invalidating local laws that protect LGBT people, these states have gone much farther than before. An LGBT individual trying to rectify and find justice for their discrimination case will find no sympathetic judge who can point to a city’s ordinance banning LGBT discrimination. Legal recourse for those who suffer discrimination is a near impossibility — something Lambda Legal and the ACLU noted in their challenges, referring to the famous Supreme Court case Romer vs Evans in 1996 that overturned Colorado’s anti-gay Amendment 2.  

But until the Supreme Court rules these laws unconstitutional, Religious Freedom laws like these, once cloaked in religious protection, are simply OKed open bigotry.

I know there is a tendency to say that these states are the exception. I think the map proves otherwise and combined with the toxicity of the current election cycle, it shows how vulnerable we are without federal protections.

Elections matter.

 

Comments

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

153 COMMENTS

  19. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Informations here: thepridela.com/2016/04/religious-freedom-laws-grow-more-onerous-and-go-viral/ […]

  37. cheap belstaff sale

    Great to be browsing your weblog again, it continues to be months for me. Well this post that ive been waited for so long. I will need this article to total my assignment in the school, and it has exact same subject with your article. Thanks, terrific…

  40. oakley sunglasses online store

    Stumbled into this website by chance but I’m sure glad I clicked on that link. You certainly answered all the questions I’ve been dying to answer for some time now. Will undeniably come back for more of this. Thank you so much

  41. Callaway Golf outlet online

    This is some agreeable stuff. It took me a while to find this internet site but it was worth the time. I noticed this content was buried in yahoo and not the first spot. This site has a ton of helpful material and it doesnt deserve to be burried in the…

  43. Barbour International Jackets

    Oh my goodness! It is like you read my mind! You seem to know so much about this, just like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the content home a bit, besides that, this is helpful blog post. A outs…

  44. clic clac bracelet hermes

    Oki. Avant sa porte se trouve le célèbre cèdre, pas remarquable par la hauteur, mais merveilleux pour la circonférence. Deux verges au-dessus thesoil sa circonférence est de quarante-cinq pieds. Il a donné son nom à l’holy118.There sont deux étangs n…

  45. chanel for sale

    kinda appreciated the article that you published . it really isnt that simple to discover even remotely good stuff toactually read (you know READ and not just browsing through it like some uniterested and flesh eating zombie before moving on), so cheer…

  49. cheap adidas shoes

    in this article. a lot more articles like yours had to comment to say It is refreshing to find people who write like they know what they are talking about

  56. wolf skin minecraft

    Thank you so much with regard to giving everyone an update on this issue on your website. Please be aware that if a brand-new post appears or in the event that any improvements occur on the current article, I would consider reading more and focusing on…

  58. merrell outlet store

    nice site. I as well woud liking how to create a site but routinely the advice is every very large or smaller. Is here a web site that could support me discover excellent niches.? I want how to experience a website that will list new trends web based a…

  59. golden goose homme pas cher

    chargé de leurs lacunes, mais aucun ne pouvait être formé des lacunes dans les fournitures ofmen. Nous ne serons pas, cependant, voir beaucoup de raisons de reget le manque de thishope, si l’on considère le peu de perspective, il est, que la plupart…

  84. Roof Cleaning Dublin

    I do not even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was great. I don’t know who you are but definitely you are going to a famous blogger if you are not already 😉 Cheers!

  85. hermes magazine

    Anglia.59. Woden engendra Casser, qui engendra Titinon, qui engendra Trigil, whobegat Rodmunt, qui engendra Rippa, qui engendra Guillem Guercha, * qui wasthe premier roi de la Angles Est. Guercha engendra Uffa, qui engendra Tytillus, qui engendra Eni,…

  86. sneakers golden goose

    Illyrie. Elle était alors une jeune fille très floraison et gracieuse offourteen ou quinze ans old.176Finally il la rencontrer une troisième fois, dix ans laterstill, en 1827-28, quand elle était dans la mi-vingtaine et il a été stoïquement enduringwh…

  87. hermes parfum

    pour ce vieux projet de loi de notre parti, Collinson, dit-il. Illsettle et de recueillir de chacun. Quelque temps quand vous venez vers la mine, et j’espère youll nous donner un appel, vous pouvez amener le cheval. Pendant ce temps youcan utiliser l…

  88. golden goose sneakers

    Esprit de Solitude1815, reflète profondément la solitude spirituelle de la deserttraveller qui poursuit une rivière périlleuse, et sait qu’il ne sera probablement jamais return.Shelleys désert, alors qu’il comprend sombre Aethiopia dans ses collines…

  89. boutique hermes bruxelles

    oeil, comme il s’équilibré sur un balancement bough.Everything autre a été oublié et à ce moment j’avais pris mes premiers Stepas un hunter.There était presque autant de différence entre les garçons indiens whowere amenés sur les prairies ouvertes e…

  90. golden goose homme pas cher

    et America.John Jeffries a écrit un rapport officiel plus à Joseph Banks à la Royal Society, qui a été publié dans le Societys Transactionsin 1786. Il n’a jamais volé à nouveau, andhis records journal privé plusieurs exclamations de remercier Dieu d…

  91. pull hermes

    ensemble! Mais penchons-nous et écoutons; wehear une voix parlant à usLONDONS UNDERWORLD79Dear M. Holmes, je suis profondément intéressé par votre travail, et je me sens onewith vous à l’esprit et le cœur dans les différents troubles de la vie humain…

  92. borse valentino 2017

    momento la signora Benedictcalled a noi, ed è venuto marciare di nuovo dalla porta, e agganciato hersupercilious, paternalistico braccio signor Copley, e gli chiese in thesitting-stanza per parlare sopra la cappella signora nella sua nuova zia memoria…

  93. borse burberry saldi

    loro che non sono noti in Prac-Tice. Sono i governi degli Stati da stigmatizzate come tirannie, becausethey possedere questo potere? Se non lo sono, con quello che può proprietà del likepower giustificare una tale carica contro il governo nazionale, o…

  94. golden goose saldi

    parla come se fosse un uomo morto o un layfigure ventriloqui. E in effetti lui è mezzo morto. Non ha mai imparato l’arte ofreleasing se stesso dalla fatica consegnandole al suo subordinates.He è permanentemente stanco. Si sente che è quasi crudele da…

  95. boutique hermes paris

    traduire therare et dialogue spécial de Fès en quelque chose de plus durable et plus large inits application pratique. Cela se traduit par une exploration permanente de dialogue avec pour UN VÉHICULE une certaine attention institutionnelle continue. E…

  96. montgomery burberry uomo

    theircaptain seguito gli indiani, ma non appena sono stati uno archibugio colpo fromthe riva, ma i soldati Berreos in agguato avuto tutti loro, nonostante il fatto che aveva dato la sua parola al capitano Whiddon che theyshould prendere l’acqua e il…

  97. ballerina burberry

    che essere costretto a combattere sito ufficiale burberry borse , essi dovrebbero superare o pneumatici outthe romani, pensando poi con le sue forze di virtù, fresco, ha couldeasily supe sito ufficiale burberry borse rare i romani già stanco. Nell’in…

  98. hermes montbron recrutement

    son ici et maintenant. nous Itchallenges dans tous les aspects de nos églises et des hôpitaux conçus des programmes spéciaux pour AIDSwidows et orphelins living.6Catholic, tandis que les services médicaux catholiques axés sur les soins et le traitemen…

  150. hermes sayat recrutement

    Shakespeare devint ensuite Anew BURLESQUES40player et fit écrire playswhich étaient acceptables même aux QueensMajestys selfand je mets ce bas pas de la vanité de montrer que j’ai heldconverse avec un tel, ni de donner un le semblant et la couleur à…

  152. cinture hermes outlet

    a un’altra serie di rocce nere, che aveva theappearance di pilastri spezzati, impostare uno dietro l’altro in un luogo grandi depth.This è stato scelto da Sir Allan per la nostra cena. Siamo stati easilyaccommodated con posti a sedere, per le pietre…

  153. cinture hermes uomo

    opposizione in embrione. Il più piccolo l’ex-tenda del territorio, tanto più difficile sarà per le persone per formare piano aregular o sistematica dell’opposizione, e più sarà facile todefeat loro primi sforzi. L’intelligenza può essere più rapida…

Comments are closed.