July 18, 2024 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

Two Supreme Court Justices Want To Overturn Marriage Equality

After the Supreme Court today rejected the appeal of Kim Davis, the Kentucky clerk who refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, Justice Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, who both oppose equal rights for LGBTQ Americans, reminded us that marriage equality is in danger when both justices wrote a lengthy discourse in defense of Davis. 

The two justices suggested that SCOTUS must overturn Obergefell v. Hodges, which recognized same-sex couples the right to marry, in order to preserve religious liberty in the United States. “Davis may have been one of the first victims of this courts’ cavalier treatment of religion in its Obergefell decision but she will not be the last.” Thomas warned. 

The dissent went on to say the court’s original ruling in Obergefell v. Hodges, which is where marriage equality was passed, created a “novel constitutional right over the religious liberty interests explicitly protected in the First Amendment” and that it enabled the government and courts to “ brand religious adherents who believe that marriage is between one man and one woman as bigots, making their religious liberty concerns that much easier to dismiss.” In essence, they maintain that marriage equality is in opposition to the First Amendment.

The case began when Davis, an employee of the Rowan County clerk’s office refused to issue marriage licenses to couples David Ermold and David Moore, and James Yates and Will Smith. The couples were rejected three times when they requested marriage licenses from Davis in 2015, who was an employee of the clerk’s office. She was subsequently fired by the county and sued by the two couples. Davis claimed she was protected by qualified immunity from any lawsuits for her refusal to abide by the law and court decision. A federal appeals court rejected her claims in a 3-0 decision.

Today’s ruling by the court means the couple’s civil case against Davis can proceed, but the dissenting opinion of the two conservative associate justices is a major cause for concern. With the passing of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg,  the Senate is likely to confirm another conservative judge who would likely also be in favor of overturning marriage equality to fill her seat. 

While the statements made by the justices put some on high alert, Timothy R. Johnson, Morse-Alumni Distinguished Professor of Political Science and Law at the University of Minnesota says that doesn’t automatically mean the court is poised to overturn marriage equality.

“I would suggest that there is some cause for concern, especially with the imminent confirmation of judge Amy Coney Barrett, who, by all accounts has very strong religious beliefs,” he said. “That said, the court actually handled two LGBTQ rights cases at the end of its term this past June. Both of those cases said that if you fire someone because he or she is gay, or because he or she is transgender that that is a violation of Title IV of the civil rights act of 1964.”

While this was before Ginburg’s passing, Johnson says she was not the pivotal role. 

“There were two conservative votes in those cases,” he continued. “Not only Chief Justice Roberts, who in fact, was a dissenter in the Obergefell case in 2015, but Justice Neil Gorsuch, Trump’s first nominee, actually wrote the opinions in those cases. So there is, in fact, currently a five person majority on the court, including the Chief Justice, who will take a second look before saying we’re going to do some harm to same-sex couples or rights that they may possess.”

Statistically speaking Justices Thomas and Alito have the minority opinion, according to a Gallop poll taken this summer, two in three Americans support same-sex marriage, matching the previous high in 2018.

Related Posts

West Hollywood to Host Community Meeting for WeHo 40 Strategic Plan

July 17, 2024

July 17, 2024

Event Invites Community Feedback, Has Performances and Exhibits The City of West Hollywood will hold a community meeting on Saturday,...

Sexual Assault Reported in South Brentwood, Suspect at Large

July 16, 2024

July 16, 2024

LAPD Confirms Incident, Community Seeks Help to Identify Man A post on Nextdoor this evening reported the shocking news that...

Elon Musk Plans to Move Twitter and SpaceX HQs Out of California

July 16, 2024

July 16, 2024

Move Follows SAFETY Act Being Signed Into Law by Governor  Elon Musk, billionaire and CEO of Twitter, Space X, and...

Judge Issues Final Ruling in Favor of Barrington Plaza Tenants Association

July 16, 2024

July 16, 2024

Decision against Landlord Finds Intent Does Not Meet Ellis Act Standards The final ruling in the case of the Barrington...

RuPaul’s DragCon Returns to the Los Angeles Convention Center This Week

July 16, 2024

July 16, 2024

Join Drag Race Queens for a Weekend of Performances, Shopping, Surprises RuPaul’s DragCon is set to return to the Los...

Governor Signs Landmark SAFETY Act to Shield LGBTQ+ Students in California Schools

July 15, 2024

July 15, 2024

New Law Prohibits Forced Outing Policies in Schools to Keep Students Safe The Support Academic Futures & Educators for Today’s...

Covid-19 Cases, Hospitalizations, and Test Positivity Rates Rise in Latest CDC Reports

July 15, 2024

July 15, 2024

California’s Wastewater COVID-19 Levels Are Very High; JN.1 Variant Dominates Covid 19 is making a comeback this summer, with infection...

LAPD and Family Seek Public’s Help to Locate Missing 69-Year-Old Woman

July 15, 2024

July 15, 2024

Beryl Angela Thomas Last Seen in Fairfax Area; May Be Disoriented The family of Beryl Angela Thomas and detectives from...

Two Arrested in Fatal Shooting on Los Angeles Metro Train in West Adams

July 14, 2024

July 14, 2024

Suspects Have Been Charged With Murder in the Death of Juan Garcia Two suspects have been arrested and charged in...

West Hollywood Sustainability Town Hall: Zero Waste and Organic Waste Implementation

July 14, 2024

July 14, 2024

Meeting to Discuss Senate Bill 1383’s Impact on Methane Reduction and Food Security The City of West Hollywood, in partnership...

Beloved Brentwood Monument Destroyed by Vandals on San Vincente Median

July 14, 2024

July 14, 2024

A Symbol of Community History and Dedication Found in Pieces One of Brentwood’s most cherished monuments was callously destroyed by...

Los Angeles Woman Sentenced to 35 Years to Life for Murder of Michael Latt

July 14, 2024

July 14, 2024

35 Years to Life for Woman Who Killed Social Justice Advocate Jameelah Michl was sentenced to 35 years to life...

Summer at Annenberg:Swim Daily and Watch the Sunset

July 12, 2024

July 12, 2024

By Susan Payne A unique, inclusive community destination along the Pacific Coast Highway of Santa Monica is inviting you to...

(Video) Two Different Angles of a Firecracker Being Tossed Into a Garage in Brentwood

July 12, 2024

July 12, 2024

A series of incidents where teens threw firecrackers have been happening in Brentwood since April. In this case, the firework...

Ben Affleck and Jennifer Garner’s Daughter Advocates for Long Covid Awareness and Safety Measures

July 11, 2024

July 11, 2024

Brentwood Resident Speaks Out Opposing Mask Bans, Calling for Covid Protections in County Facilities Violet Affleck, daughter of actors Ben...