December 26, 2024 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

It’s Neil Gorsuch, say SCOTUS watchers

Donald Trump has reportedly chosen Neil Gorsuch, a United States Circuit Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, to fill the seat of deceased Supreme Court of the United States Justice Antonin Scalia.

(also read:  Christian conservatives insist on ‘religious liberties’ through executive order )

Though Scalia died in February 2016, Republicans successfully prevented President Barack Obama from naming his successor. Obama had selected Merrick Garland to replace Scalia but Republicans in the Senate refused to consider him, fearing the loss of a conservative seat on the court.

Gorsuch is a social conservative who authored a book that argued against legalization of assisted suicide and euthanasia.  He sided with religious employers seeking to limit their employees’ rights to birth control coverage in the lower court decision in Hobby Lobby, and, in greater context, fought against the federal health care law’s birth-control mandate.

Gorsuch was also outspoken against the Obama administration’s enactment of progressive labor and environmental executive orders and grew almost singularly focused on preventing federal agencies from having any independent ability to interpret or to enforce them.

Gorsuch is, in part, the perfect neo-con response to the question of executive orders and whether the executive — Obama — exceeded appropriate bounds that should be reined in by the courts. Trump may not have considered his own potential future need to exert executive authority when he encounters an obstructive legislative branch.

Such a profile could be seen as consistent with the Trump doctrine of keeping agencies in check and limiting the scope of their reach.  Trump has so far chosen critics to lead government agencies, many of whom are opposed to the very function and missions of the agency they will run.  Obama administration cabinet members, Trump supporters like to point out, issued over 97,000 pages of regulations in 2016 alone, all of them requiring agency enforcement and interpretation.

Republicans recently passed a bill that effectively strips agencies from their rule making ability.

While Gorsuch’s selection is clearly a slap in the face to women’s reproductive rights, workers rights and environmental laws and regulations, the impact on LGBT rights is embedded in those arguments. 

Gorsuch’s opposition to the ability of agencies to interpret the scope of their power and reach is a warning shot to LGBT advocates who have by necessity come to rely — in some instances — on agencies of government for enforcement. 

Gorsuch’s Hobby Lobby decision is also a clear signal of support from Trump for Religious Freedom Bills championed by some conservatives, pioneered by Vice President Mike Pence. Such bills seek to shelters corporations and, in certain instances, citizens, who wish to discriminate against individuals who they deem a burden to their exercise of religious faith (the instance of a baker being forced to create a wedding cake for a same-sex couple is the most famous and benign argument). 

The threat to LGBT rights is not unlike the threat posed by Justice Antonin Scalia, whom, if Gorsuch is nominated by Trump and approved by Congress, he would replace.  

However, some argue the threat may be greater since Scalia was not opposed to the Chevron rule, which allows agencies the power of rule making and enforcement.

University of Denver law professor Justin Marceau told the Denver Post that “Gorsuch would be Scalia’s ‘intellectual equal and almost certainly his equal on conservative jurisprudential approaches to criminal justice and social justice issues that are bound to keep coming up in the country,’ although Gorsuch may not be as ‘combative’ as Scalia was on the court.”

Gorsuch was appointed to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals by President George W. Bush in 2006. Previously he was a Marshall Scholar at the University of Oxford, graduated from Harvard Law School, clerked for prominent conservative judges (Judge David Sentelle of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, as well as Justices Byron White and Anthony Kennedy of the Supreme Court), and was a high-ranking official in the Bush Justice Department before his judicial appointment.

in NEWS
Related Posts

The Best and Most Intriguing NYE Celebrations on the Westside

December 25, 2024

December 25, 2024

Check Out These Options for Your New Year’s Dinner & Drinks Alice B., the newest creation of the duo behind...

Vietnam War Veteran Killed in Santa Monica Hit-and-Run on Wilshire

December 25, 2024

December 25, 2024

Police Seek Public’s Help in Identifying Suspect After Fatal Collision The life of a Vietnam War veteran was extinguished in...

Film Review: The Brutalist

December 24, 2024

December 24, 2024

By Dolores Quintana Filled with grandeur as stark as the Brutalist architecture designed by László Tóth, The Brutalist is epic...

City of West Hollywood Shares Holiday Trash and Recycling Updates

December 23, 2024

December 23, 2024

Holiday Collection Schedules and Tips for Tree Recycling in the City  The City of West Hollywood is reminding residents about...

Metro Los Angeles Offers Free Holiday Rides For the Holidays, Exclusive Event Perks

December 23, 2024

December 23, 2024

Celebrate the Season With Free Rides, Special Surprises, Discounted Access  Metro is making it easier for Los Angeles residents and...

First Human Case of H5 Bird Flu Confirmed in Los Angeles County

December 23, 2024

December 23, 2024

Exposure to Raw or Undercooked Animal Products Pose Risks A human case of H5 bird flu has been confirmed in...

LA County Launches Pilot Program to Help RV Residents Transition to Permanent Housing

December 23, 2024

December 23, 2024

New Initiative Offers Safe Parking, Support Services, and a Pathway To Stable Housing Los Angeles County has launched the Pathway...

Film Review: Nosferatu

December 22, 2024

December 22, 2024

By Dolores Quintana Claws encased in a velvet glove. The audience helplessly feels Death’s wings enveloping the characters. Robert Egger’s...

West Hollywood Promotes Economic Benefits of San Vicente-Fairfax Route for Metro K Line North

December 22, 2024

December 22, 2024

New Analysis Shows the Proposed K Line North Route Could Generate Billions The City of West Hollywood is promoting the...

LA Public Health Officials Warn Against Raw Milk Consumption Amid Bird Flu Outbreak

December 20, 2024

December 20, 2024

Second California Recall Affects Unpasteurized Milk; Risk of Illness to Humans and Pets The Los Angeles County Department of Public...

LA Sheriff’s Department Seeks Public’s Help to Find West Hollywood Man John Joseph Mallon III

December 19, 2024

December 19, 2024

Missing West Hollywood Man Needs Medication and Is Considered At Risk The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department’s Missing Persons Unit...

Experience Elevated Brunch Vibes at LAVO West Hollywood with Live DJ and Luxe Cocktails

December 19, 2024

December 19, 2024

Indulge in a $46 Three-Course Brunch With Shareable Cocktail Trees, Signature Drinks,  LAVO West Hollywood, known for its upscale Italian...

LASD Deputy Pleads Guilty to Civil Rights Violation in Assault of Transgender Man

December 19, 2024

December 19, 2024

Sheriff’s Deputy Faces 10 Years in Prison for Excessive Force, Attempted Cover-up A Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department deputy has...

California Governor Declares State of Emergency Amid Bird Flu Outbreak in Dairy Cattle

December 18, 2024

December 18, 2024

Governor Newsom’s Action Expands the State’s Response to the H5N1 Virus Governor Gavin Newsom declared a State of Emergency today...

Krispy Kreme and Lodge Bread Unite for Limited-Edition Hanukkah Sufganiyot

December 18, 2024

December 18, 2024

Only for a Limited Time and in Limited Quantities for This Special Collaboration Krispy Kreme and Los Angeles-based bakery Lodge...