Authors and Judges Withdraw in Protest of TERF Author’s Statements
The Polari Prize, one of the U.K.’s best-known LGBTQ+ literary awards, is under fire ahead of its 15th anniversary after longlisting novelist John Boyne, prompting withdrawals by multiple nominees and two judges.
The dispute erupted after the Aug. 1 longlist named Boyne’s novel “Earth.” Critics cite Boyne’s past statements, he has described himself as a “TERF,” or trans-exclusionary radical feminist, and a recent birthday essay praising J.K. Rowling, whose views on transgender issues have drawn protests.
Prize organizers acknowledged the “hurt and anger” the decision sparked but defended the nomination, saying, “We can at times hold radically different positions on substantive issues. This is one of those times.” The committee said it will conduct a full review of its process and consult community representatives before next year’s awards, but has chosen to continue the award process regardless.
Reaction has been swift. Twelve authors and two judges have publicly withdrawn, and more than 800 writers and publishing figures signed an open letter urging Boyne’s removal, calling his inclusion “inexcusable” amid what they described as rising anti-trans hostility. Some nominees have chosen to remain. Avi Ben-Zeev said leaving would “erase my trans story,” arguing that withdrawal would “let transphobic ideologues win.”
Shortlists are due in September, with winners to be announced in November.
