August 20, 2025 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

Judge Rules in Favor of Tenants in Historic West Los Angeles Eviction Case

Landlord’s Eviction Plan Under Ellis Act Rejected, Tenants Can Stay

After a lengthy legal battle that spanned over a year, a Los Angeles Superior Court judge has tentatively ruled in favor of the defendants, who formed the Barrington Plaza Tenants Association, in the largest mass eviction in Los Angeles history under the Ellis Act. Barrington Plaza is a West Los Angeles apartment complex with 712 apartments that has suffered two recent fires, one of which resulted in the death of a tenant. 

The landlord, Barrington Pacific, an LLC connected to Douglas Emmett, invoked the Ellis Act in May of 2023, saying that they intended to make upgrades in the building that would require all tenants to be evicted. 

Many of the protections that renters had during the pandemic have expired, leaving them vulnerable to potential evictions or increased rents, so this case was of great interest to renters and landlords alike.  

On June 13, Judge H. Jay Ford III ruled against Douglas Emmett, a Maryland corporation, and Barrington Pacific LLC, a California-based LLC. Ford found that the landlord’s actions did not meet the standard of the Ellis Act, namely that they were “going out of business” and did not intend to place the rental units at Barrington Plaza back on the market and that this plan violated the city’s Rent Stabilization Ordinance.  

The ruling stated, “…when Barrington Pacific filed its Notice of Intent to Withdraw Units from Rental Housing Use with the City and served its notice of termination on its tenants, Barrington Pacific did not intend to permanently remove those apartments from the rental market under the RSO or otherwise intend to go out of business as contemplated under the Ellis Act. But rather. Barrington Pacific had the intent to temporarily withdraw the apartments in Barrington Plaza from rental use with the specific intent to relet those apartments as soon as it completed its planned renovations to all the apartments, including installing fire and safety improvements, sprinklers, and other modernization upgrades, all of which Barrington Pacific planned for and expected would take three to five years to complete.”

This means that the 100 tenants who are still living in the apartment building can stay pending the final version of the ruling, which will take effect after a time period given to the plaintiff to object. 

Barrington Plaza tenant Monique Gomez said in a statement released by the Coalition for Economic Survival, “We have been fighting these bogus evictions for over a year now. Tenants here have faced harassment, intimidation, and uncertainty without little to no help from the city. It shows that when we stick together, we can win. I am overjoyed.”

Larry Gross, executive director for the Coalition for Economic Survival, stated, “This is, no doubt, one of the most important tenants’ rights legal victory in state history.”

Douglass Emmett and Barrington Pacific told the LAist that a decision had not been made on whether or not the landlord intends to appeal, but that work on the building will continue.

Related Posts

Heat Wave to Hit L.A. as Fire Risk, Possible Thunderstorms, and High Temps Loom

August 19, 2025

August 19, 2025

Governor Newsom Pre-Deploys Crews Ahead of Dangerous Heat and Fire Weather  Dangerous heat is expected to grip Southern California starting...

‘Ketamine Queen’ Pleads Guilty and Admits Role in Matthew Perry’s Death

August 19, 2025

August 19, 2025

Prosecutors Say She Supplied Ketamine Through Perry’s Assistant Facing five federal counts tied to Matthew Perry’s 2023 overdose, North Hollywood...

Polari Prize Canceled for 2025 Amid Boyne Controversy

August 18, 2025

August 18, 2025

Organizers Halt LGBTQ+ Literary Awards After Backlash The Polari Prize, one of the U.K.’s leading LGBTQ+ literary honors, will not...

HelloFresh to Pay $7.5M in Subscription Renewal Case Filed by CART Prosecutors

August 18, 2025

August 18, 2025

Meal-Kit Giant Settles Lawsuit Over Automatic Plan Payments Without Proper Consent HelloFresh has agreed to pay roughly $7.5 million to...

Dan Tana, Founder of Hollywood’s Iconic Celebrity Eatery, Dies at 90

August 18, 2025

August 18, 2025

West Hollywood’s Iconic Red-Sauce Spot Loses Its Former Owner Dan Tana, the actor-turned-restaurateur who created one of Hollywood’s most enduring...

“Off/The Clock” Returns: A Bold Four-Course Dining Experience by Chef Diego Argoti

August 18, 2025

August 18, 2025

An Audacious Four-Course Menu Only at Neuehouse Hollywood. NeueHouse Hollywood will host a one-night culinary showcase on Wednesday, August 20...

Spelling Manor Sells for $110M, July’s Priciest U.S. Home Deal is in Los Angeles

August 18, 2025

August 18, 2025

Holmby Hills Estate Once Owned by Aaron Spelling Tops Redfin’s Monthly List The former estate of television producer Aaron Spelling...

American Horror Story Actress Sarah Paulson Finds Buyer for Hollywood Hills Home in Just 3 Weeks

August 18, 2025

August 18, 2025

The Emmy- and Tony-winning actress Listed Midcentury Property for $2.995m Actress Sarah Paulson has secured a buyer for her Hollywood...

Louis Naidorf, Architect of the Santa Monica Civic, Capitol Records Building, Dies at 96

August 17, 2025

August 17, 2025

Designer Also Shaped Landmarks From the Beverly Center to the California State Capitol Louis Naidorf, the architect who designed Hollywood’s...

Polari Prize in Turmoil: John Boyne Nomination Causes Mass Resignations

August 16, 2025

August 16, 2025

Authors and Judges Withdraw in Protest of TERF Author’s Statements The Polari Prize, one of the U.K.’s best-known LGBTQ+ literary...

Two Arrested in Culver City E-Bike Shooting; Cache of Guns, Suspected Cocaine Seized

August 16, 2025

August 16, 2025

Victim Wounded After Resisting Robbery on Sepulveda Boulevard Two women have been arrested in connection with the Aug. 4 shooting...

Tesla Diner Slashes Menu Weeks After Grand Opening in Hollywood

August 16, 2025

August 16, 2025

Diner Narrows Offerings, Faces Protests and Lawsuit Amid Early Hype Tesla’s new retro-style diner and drive-in has already deep sixed...

Fiery 10 Freeway Chase Ends in Multi-Car Crash, Five Injured After Suspects Toss Batteries

August 15, 2025

August 15, 2025

Deputies Say a Stolen SUV Caused Chaos, Ending Car Explosion Car-chase suspects tossing car batteries from a stolen Lexus SUV...

Bell LGBTQ+ Resource Center Targeted With Bags of Dog Feces

August 15, 2025

August 15, 2025

Staff Say Repeated Overnight Attacks Raise Safety Concerns Bags of dog waste have been repeatedly tossed at an LGBTQ+ youth...

Fire at Beverly Hills’ Funke Prompts Evacuation, No Injuries Reported

August 15, 2025

August 15, 2025

Blaze in Exhaust System Forces Temporary Closure Flames erupted in the exhaust system at Funke Restaurant on Tuesday night, prompting...