February 11, 2025 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

Supreme Court Debates Legality of Ticketing Homeless Individuals, Hears Grants Pass Case

Landmark Case Raises Questions of Cruel and Unusual Punishment

The Supreme Court engaged in a lengthy debate on Monday, lasting more than two and a half hours, over whether ticketing homeless individuals constitutes “cruel and unusual” punishment, potentially violating the Eighth Amendment, as reported by CNN.

Several justices expressed concerns regarding the criminalization of homelessness while also acknowledging the necessity for cities to address public health and fire hazards in homeless encampments nationwide.

In an exchange, Justice Sotomayor asked, “Where do we put them if every city, every village, every town lacks compassion?”

The attorney representing Grants Pass, Ms. Theane D. Evangelis, started to answer and said, We,” but Justice Sotomayor continued and said, “and passes a law identical to this? Where are they supposed to sleep? Are they supposed to kill themselves, not sleeping?

Justice Elena Kagan highlighted the fundamental need for sleep, comparing it to breathing, and questioned the ethical implications of penalizing individuals for sleeping in public spaces when they have nowhere else to go.

The focus of the argument centered on whether the “anti-camping” ordinances in Grants Pass, Oregon, targeted specific conduct, such as sleeping with bedding in public areas or the state of being homeless. The city contends that the ordinances primarily address conduct, whereas plaintiffs argue that enforcement disproportionately targets unhoused individuals.

Under these ordinances, police regularly issue citations to individuals sleeping in parks and other public spaces. Violations incur a $295 fine, which escalates to over $500 if left unpaid.

This case marks a significant appeal concerning unhoused Americans to reach the Supreme Court in decades, garnering close attention from municipalities and states grappling with rising homelessness rates.

According to the US Department of Housing and Urban Development, over 650,000 people experience homelessness in the United States on any given night, reflecting a 12% increase from 2022 to 2023.

Chief Justice John Roberts and other conservative justices raised questions about the ordinance’s explicit language, noting its silence on prohibiting homelessness and the challenge of defining someone’s status as “homeless,” which can fluctuate nightly.

The court contemplated the distinction between status and conduct, a pivotal consideration due to a 1962 Supreme Court ruling that found criminalizing drug addiction – a status – amounted to “cruel and unusual” punishment under the Eighth Amendment.

Residents experiencing homelessness in Grants Pass initiated the lawsuit. The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in their favor, asserting that the city could not enforce anticamping ordinances against homeless individuals for sleeping outside or in their cars when no alternative shelter was available.

Grants Pass officials argue that the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on “cruel and unusual” punishment pertains to torture or hard labor sentences, not citations.

A verdict in the City of Grants Pass v. Johnson case is anticipated before the end of June.

in NEWS
Related Posts

What about are you protected from future wildfires?

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

Our hearts go out to all those impacted by the recent wildfires and Santa Ana windstorms in Southern California. We...

Actor Will Arnett Lists Stunning Beverly Hills-Area Home for $22.5 Million

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

Comedy Star’s Modern Farmhouse Features Custom Podcast Studio Actor and comedian Will Arnett is selling his modern farmhouse-style home near...

Shore Hotel Remains Sustainability Leader

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

By Susan Payne On track to open its new coastal-inspired restaurant, Shore Hotel has excited new offerings and initiatives this...

Help Shape the Future of Hart Park, Attend West Hollywood’s Public Meetings in February

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

WeHo Seeks Community Input on ADA Upgrades, Dog Park, and Safety Enhancements The City of West Hollywood is inviting community...

West Hollywood’s Tallest Tower Moves Forward with Environmental Review

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

Proposed 34-Story Mixed-Use High-Rise Would Bring 514 Apartments A proposed 34-story high-rise that could become the tallest building in West...

Rescheduled 2024 Homeless Count Needs More Volunteers on the Westside

February 9, 2025

February 9, 2025

Not Enough Volunteers to Successfully Count Unhoused Angelenos This Year With the rescheduled dates for the 2025 Greater Los Angeles...

Student Protest Over Immigration Policies Leads to Walkouts Across the Westside

February 7, 2025

February 7, 2025

Walkout Turns Tense as Counter-Protester Confronts Teen in Video From Venice Students from Santa Monica High School (SAMOHI), Culver City...

Open Arms Art Show Runs Through Mar. 22 in Burbank

February 6, 2025

February 6, 2025

Opening Exhibition Saturday Feb. 8 from 12 to 8p.m. More than an art show, the Open Arms Exhibition is an...

Quiet Luxury: What’s Inside the New Regent Boutique and Sweet July

February 6, 2025

February 6, 2025

The Regent Santa Monica Beach, known for its perfect Santa Monica getaways, or local dining at its Mediterranean-based restaurant Orla...

West Hollywood Deputies Arrest San Bernardino Homicide Suspect on Sierra Bonita

February 6, 2025

February 6, 2025

Man Wanted for Deadly Baseball Bat Attack Captured During Routine Patrol Deputies from the West Hollywood Sheriff’s Station apprehended a...

Serial Predator David Pearce Convicted of Murders, Rape in Shocking Fentanyl Overdose Case in West LA

February 6, 2025

February 6, 2025

“Dead Girls Don’t Talk,” Fake Producer Abandoned Women’s Bodies Like Garbage A jury convicted David Brian Pearce of two counts...

Best Spots to Celebrate Valentines, Galentines, or Have a Super Bowl Party on the Westside

February 5, 2025

February 5, 2025

Cocktails, Game Day Grub, Valentine’s Pasta, and a Lonely Heart’s Tea Service You will find many excellent ways to celebrate...

FDA Issues High-Risk Recall for Pre-Packaged Broccoli Florets Sold at Walmart

February 5, 2025

February 5, 2025

Recall Is Now Classified as Class I Due to Seriousness Of Contamination The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has classified...

Matū Kai Brings Its Signature Wagyu and Famous Cheesesteak to Brentwood

February 5, 2025

February 5, 2025

Team Behind Beverly Hills’ Acclaimed Matū Is Opening a Second Location One of Beverly Hills’s newest and most popular restaurants,...

West Hollywood’s Drag Story Hour Returns for 2025 Season This Week

February 4, 2025

February 4, 2025

Family-Friendly Storytelling Series Celebrates Diversity and Inclusion The City of West Hollywood will launch its 2025 season of Drag Story...