January 29, 2023 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

Is California Failing Lesbian Couples?

There’s an old myth about lesbians and Victorian England that you’ve probably heard about one way or another–you might even have thought it was true at one point. Although homosexuality was famously criminalized during Queen Victoria’s reign, any specific reference to lesbian sex acts was left out, according to the fact that (they say) Victoria refused to believe lesbians existed.

While the anecdote is most likely untrue, it’s important to think about. Although our era may feel less primitive than Queen Victoria’s in certain ways, in many others, oppressive remnants of the Victorian age live on.

  Throughout history, a feigned ignorance about (or pure denial of) lesbian individuals and partnerships has lead to two things: An ability to fly beneath the radar of certain restrictive lifestyle-based laws, and a total and utter lack of representation.

Today, this lack of representation, both in the media and in politics, is harming lesbians more than ever. Two cases in California this week show just how underserved the lesbian population is, despite the progress we’ve made in the fight for LGBTQ+ rights. In the eyes of too many companies, politicians, and state laws, lesbians relationships are still viewed as invalid.

Take Judith Dominguez and her wife Patricia Martinez. The two women live in Alhambra and have been together for 29 years, having tied the knot officially in 2013 when the Supreme Court finally legalized gay marriage on a federal level. For years the women have enjoyed coverage from the joint health care Dominguez received from her job. That is, until this January, when Dominguez re-enrolled only to be told her 29-year-long relationship did not meet her insurance’s “one man, one woman” criteria for spousal benefits. Dominguez filed a suit and was met with a vicious counter-suit by the insurance company. But not before they made sure her health plan was retroactively canceled, resulting in tens of thousands of dollars in debt for services already performed and cleared by insurance.

    It doesn’t seem like something that could happen in California, or anywhere across the anti-Trump oasis of the West Coast. But cases like Dominguez’s are becoming more common in the wake of Trump’s election. Dominguez’s attorney Dan Stormer has been able to see the change first hand, in civil rights court cases across the state. “It is absolutely clear to us that once Trump was elected, these people saw their opportunity to carry out their bigotry,” Stormer told the Los Angeles Times, “[and] that without the election of Trump, the [federal] Civil Rights Division would clearly have moved on them, would clearly have determined that their actions were unlawful.”

Meanwhile, in Los Angeles, another years-long fight was coming to a close.

White and Videckis have been fighting Pepperdine on a discrimination charge since 2014. Just this month, they lost the case.

Back in 2014, two college basketball players filed a lawsuit for discriminating against them because they were in a relationship with each other. Plaintiffs Layana White and Haley Videckis claimed that their coach at Pepperdine University had harassed them for their sexual orientation and blamed them (specifically their relationship) for losing games. Not only did Videckis and White claim that they were discriminated by their coach but also by the university, which failed to process White’s NCAA appeal to become eligible to play for the 2014-15 season after her transfer to Pepperdine.

Pepperdine University is a private Christian university that “Niche” ranks as the 9th most conservative college in California and one of the more conservative universities in the United States. It is located in Malibu and is undoubtedly, as the plaintiffs’ lawyer described, “not a great university to be gay in,” according to the Los Angeles Times. The former players of the university’s basketball league stated the multiple times that the staff tried to pry into their relationship with questions about sleeping arrangements to gynecology records. The university even tried to argue that Title IX, which protects athletes in schools from gender discrimination, does not extend to protection against discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation.

The case was closed in early August, with the jury coming down on the side of University on the basis of a lack of evidence. The case still remains a landmark suit by being the first to go to trial under the Title IX law. When the case was ruled by a federal judge to fall under Title IX, it propelled it to trial and ultimately told the American people that LGBTQ discrimination is inextricably linked to discrimination based on gender.

The case not only gave LGBTQ athletes representation and courage to pursue legal action against discrimination in an academic setting but also marked the first of its kind under the Title IX law, further proving its importance. If another academic institution tries to create a loophole through denying LGBTQ+ protection from discrimination in Title IX, the 2015 case ruling by the federal judge who allowed Videckis and White Vs. Pepperdine University to go trial will remain a starting point for fighting against it. That landmark 2015 ruling by a California Federal judge opened up the Title IX anti-discrimination measure (first instituted in 1972) to apply to discrimination based on sexual orientation as well, giving Layana White and Haley Videckis their well-deserved spot in history.

But what good is a spot in history when the current legal system keeps failing you? Just this May, the two women underwent psychological evaluations to measure the extent of the stress caused by the lawsuit as well as their exclusion from the team. The moral of the case, if there is one, is that lesbian and queer-identified women continue to suffer from not being considered, heard, or taken seriously in our society at large.

These cases can be taken as examples of Trump’s presidency has already started a wave of unpleasant changes in our court systems. They can also, however, be seen as progress. As women continue to be ignored and ill-treated by the government, they learn to push back harder every time.

Related Posts

Jurors Unable to Reach Verdict in Fatal Crash Trial

January 20, 2023

January 20, 2023

By Susan Payne A 33-year-old transgender woman was convicted on Jan. 9 for a hit-and-run with permanent and serious injury...

San Francisco Launches Guaranteed Income for Transgender People Program

January 20, 2023

January 20, 2023

By Susan Payne San Francisco has launched a pilot program that guarantees income for transgender residents.  The Guaranteed Income for...

AIDS/LifeCycle Announces New Santa Monica Beachside Finish Line

January 19, 2023

January 19, 2023

545-mile bike ride to finish in Santa Monica June 10 AIDS/LifeCycle, the seven-day, 545-mile bike ride fundraiser traversing the golden...

California Protects Out-of-State Parents, Youth Seeking Gender-Affirming Care

January 12, 2023

January 12, 2023

By Susan Payne  Over 20 states have aimed to limit youth LGBTQ+ gender-affirming health care in 2022, but California is...

LGBTQ+ Side Quest Written in God of War Ragnarok

January 12, 2023

January 12, 2023

By Susan Payne Sony Santa Monica has hidden a tragic LGBTQ_ side quest in its God of War Ragnarok game,...

Senior LGBT Retirement Development in Palm Springs to Open in 2023

January 12, 2023

January 12, 2023

By Susan Payne  For LGBTQ folks looking for a supportive community in Palm Springs, Living Out is now accepting reservations...

Man With Gun Spotted Inside West Hollywood, Spurring Fear

December 26, 2022

December 26, 2022

By Susan Payne Weeks after a deadly mass shooting in a Colorado LGBTQ+ club, a man in a West Hollywood...

Gay Actor’s Affection for Date ‘Unwelcome’ at LA Restaurant

December 26, 2022

December 26, 2022

By Susan Payne  Support is being poured for a gay actor who was on a date at a Mexican restaurant...

OR Bar WeHo Now Open in West Hollywood

December 26, 2022

December 26, 2022

By Susan Payne West Hollywood welcomed a new gay bar in the city this month. OR Bar WeHo, located at...

LA County Hate Crimes Reach Highest Level in 20 Years

December 19, 2022

December 19, 2022

Results from  Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations show hates crimes are are among the highest seen since 2002...

Third Former Major League Baseball Players Comes out as Gay

December 19, 2022

December 19, 2022

By Susan Payne This December, love is taking the place of the shame for former major league baseball player T.J....

Former Transgender City Employee Violently Arrested in West Hollywood

December 19, 2022

December 19, 2022

By Susan Payne The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department in West Hollywood violently arrested a disabled transgender woman inside of...

Gay, HIV-Positive Latino Man Sues Local Bank for Wrongful Firing

December 8, 2022

December 8, 2022

By Susan Payne A Latino man is suing Pasadena-based East West Bank and two branch management members, alleging that he...

Gunman Sentenced to 21 Years in Prison for Shooting Lady Gaga’s Dog Walker

December 8, 2022

December 8, 2022

By Susan Payne The man who shot then 30-year-old Ryan Fischer, a gay professional dog walker in Hollywood in February...

Body Found in Malibu Identified by Family as Transgender Woman

December 8, 2022

December 8, 2022

Day Roda was a member of the Los Angeles LGBT Center, organization says in expressing condolences By Susan Payne A...