December 6, 2024 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

Neil Gorsuch, a Religious Freedom advocate, Trump’s SCOTUS pick

BY TROY MASTERS  |  Donald Trump has chosen Neil Gorsuch, a United States Circuit Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, to fill the seat of deceased Supreme Court of the United States Justice Antonin Scalia.

Though Scalia died in February 2016, Republicans successfully prevented President Barack Obama from naming his successor. Obama had selected Merrick Garland to replace Scalia but Republicans in the Senate refused to consider him, fearing the loss of a conservative seat on the court.

Gorsuch is a social conservative who authored a book that argued against legalization of assisted suicide and euthanasia.  He sided with religious employers seeking to limit their employees’ rights to birth control coverage in the lower court decision in Hobby Lobby, and, in greater context, fought against the federal health care law’s birth-control mandate.

Gorsuch was also outspoken against the Obama administration’s enactment of progressive labor and environmental executive orders and grew almost singularly focused on preventing federal agencies from having any independent ability to interpret or to enforce them.

Gorsuch is, in part, the perfect neo-con response to the question of executive orders and whether the executive — Obama — exceeded appropriate bounds that should be reined in by the courts. Trump may not have considered his own potential future need to exert executive authority when he encounters an obstructive legislative branch.

Such a profile could be seen as consistent with the Trump doctrine of keeping agencies in check and limiting the scope of their reach.  Trump has so far chosen critics to lead government agencies, many of whom are opposed to the very function and missions of the agency they will run.  Obama administration cabinet members, Trump supporters like to point out, issued over 97,000 pages of regulations in 2016 alone, all of them requiring agency enforcement and interpretation.

Republicans recently passed a bill that effectively strips agencies from their rule making ability.

While Gorsuch’s selection is clearly a slap in the face to women’s reproductive rights, workers rights and environmental laws and regulations, the impact on LGBT rights is embedded in those arguments. 

Gorsuch’s opposition to the ability of agencies to interpret the scope of their power and reach is a warning shot to LGBT advocates who have by necessity come to rely — in some instances — on agencies of government for enforcement. 

Gorsuch’s Hobby Lobby decision is also a clear signal of support from Trump for Religious Freedom Bills championed by some conservatives, pioneered by Vice President Mike Pence. Such bills seek to shelters corporations and, in certain instances, citizens, who wish to discriminate against individuals who they deem a burden to their exercise of religious faith (the instance of a baker being forced to create a wedding cake for a same-sex couple is the most famous and benign argument). 

The threat to LGBT rights is not unlike the threat posed by Justice Antonin Scalia, whom, if Gorsuch is nominated by Trump and approved by Congress, he would replace.  Gorsuch was a clerk to Byron White, the staunch conservative Justice who wrote the dissenting opinion in Bowers v. Hardwick, a landmark gay rights case.

1n 1986, Justice Byron White argued that the Court had previously acted to protect rights not easily identifiable in the Constitution only when those rights are “implicit in the concept of ordered liberty” (Palko v. Connecticut, 1937) or when they are “deeply rooted in the Nation’s history and tradition” (Griswold v. Connecticut, 1965). The Court held that the right to commit sodomy did not meet either of these standards. White feared that guaranteeing a right to sodomy would be the product of “judge-made constitutional law” and send the Court down the road of illegitimacy.

That ruling was overturned by another case in 2003.

He also clerked for Justice Kennedy who years later helped make gay marriage the law of the land.

However, some argue the threat may be greater since Scalia was not opposed to the Chevron rule, which allows agencies the power of rule making and enforcement.

University of Denver law professor Justin Marceau told the Denver Post that “Gorsuch would be Scalia’s ‘intellectual equal and almost certainly his equal on conservative jurisprudential approaches to criminal justice and social justice issues that are bound to keep coming up in the country,’ although Gorsuch may not be as ‘combative’ as Scalia was on the court.”

Gorsuch was appointed to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals by President George W. Bush in 2006. Previously he was a Marshall Scholar at the University of Oxford, graduated from Harvard Law School, clerked for prominent conservative judges (Judge David Sentelle of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, as well as Justices Byron White and Anthony Kennedy of the Supreme Court), and was a high-ranking official in the Bush Justice Department before his judicial appointment.

Los Angeles LGBT Center CEO Lorri L. Jean said, “I’m extremely concerned by President’s Trump’s nomination of Neil Gorsuch to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court. His judicial philosophy and record is as out of the mainstream as any nominee could be, and the fact that he describes himself as the ‘second coming of Antonin Scalia’—the most notoriously anti-LGBT Justice to ever serve on the nation’s highest court—should be alarming to all. We urge all fair-minded people to call their senators and urge them to conduct an extreme vetting of Judge Gorsuch. If he cannot unequivocally say that the Supreme Court’s decisions upholding the constitutional freedom and equality of LGBT people over the last 20 years are—and will—remain the law of the land, then he must be rejected.”

 

in NEWS
Related Posts

GMCLA Begins 46th Season with Candy-Themed Wonderland

December 6, 2024

December 6, 2024

SugarPlum Fairies Slated for Mid-December By Susan Payne Gay Men’s Chorus of Los Angeles is bringing candy-coated goodness to its...

Pacific Park’s Famous Pacific Wheel Just Got a Fun (and Educational) NewUpgrade

December 6, 2024

December 6, 2024

Riding the Ferris wheel at Pacific Park just got even more enjoyable. Now, along with the incredible views of the...

West Hollywood to Host Virtual Meeting on Managing Coyote Encounters

December 6, 2024

December 6, 2024

Officials to Address Recent Rise in Coyote Sightings in City Streets The City of West Hollywood will hold a virtual...

Raising Cane’s Halts Plan to Convert Iconic Norms in West Hollywood

December 5, 2024

December 5, 2024

The Fast-Food Chain Withdraws Its Proposal Amid Public Opposition Raising Cane’s, the popular chicken finger chain has withdrawn its proposal...

Werewolves: Steven C. Miller’s Thrilling New Film in Theatres December 6

December 5, 2024

December 5, 2024

Watch Interviews with Star Frank Grillo and Director Steven C. Miller   What if a supermoon could unleash humanity’s darkest instincts?...

Audit Launched Into LA Animal Services Amid Rising Euthanasia Rates and Shelter Concerns

December 5, 2024

December 5, 2024

Controller Kenneth Mejia Seeks To Assess Care, Adoption Efforts, Funding Challenges Los Angeles City Controller Kenneth Mejia announced a performance...

Beloved Brentwood Restaurant New York Bagel Co. Announces Last Day of Service

December 5, 2024

December 5, 2024

Dr. Dave, One of Their Most Devoted Customers, Speaks of the Community’s Loss Patra Cichowski, co-owner and wife of Ted...

(Video) Safely Home Again Finds Care For Those Returning From Hospitals or Rehabilitation

December 5, 2024

December 5, 2024

Go To SafelyHomeAgain.com For More Information Go To https://t.co/sJ9LlL8s1h For More Information pic.twitter.com/EM1Mk4kahI — CCNewsLA (@CCWNNews) December 5, 2024

Reconnect with the Season’s Spirit with Sound Healing and Persian Traditions at La Peer Hotel

December 4, 2024

December 4, 2024

Experience a Transformative Evening of Relaxation and Culinary Delights The La Peer Hotel invites guests to mark the Winter Solstice...

Celebrate the Holidays in Style at Regent Santa Monica Beach At Chef Michael Mina’s Orla

December 4, 2024

December 4, 2024

Enjoy Brunch With Santa and a Mediterranean-inspired Christmas Dinner at Orla Celebrate the 2024 holiday season at the Regent Santa...

Raw Farm Sales Suspended, All Products Recalled, LA Public Health Issues Warning

December 4, 2024

December 4, 2024

Multiple Detections of Bird Flu at Facility Cause Statewide Recall of All Products The Los Angeles County Department of Public...

(Video) Check Out The Freshly-Revamped Santa Monica Hotel

December 4, 2024

December 4, 2024

More Info at SantaMonicaHotel.com More Info at https://t.co/nN8idbe9vT pic.twitter.com/NrzKeViHrS — Palisades News (@PalisadesNewsLA) December 4, 2024

Nathan Hochman Sworn In as L.A. County District Attorney By Arnold Schwarzenegger

December 3, 2024

December 3, 2024

Former Prosecutor Promises Focus On Public Safety and Reform Nathan Hochman, a former federal prosecutor, and Assistant U.S. Attorney General...

Downtown Culver City to Host 2024 Amazing Holiday Tree Lighting ‘Sled-tacular’

December 3, 2024

December 3, 2024

50 Tons of Snow, Live Performances, and a Magical Tree Lighting Ceremony Culver City is almost ready for the 2024...

Gotham Awards Spotlight LGBTQ+ Talent with Wins for Vera Drew and Colman Domingo

December 3, 2024

December 3, 2024

LGBTQ Artists Deliver Heartfelt Speeches as They Take Home Top Honors The Gotham Film & Media Institute celebrated the 34th...