November 26, 2022 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

In Tyler Clementi webcam case, bias conviction overturned

clemBREAKING:  Tyler Clementi committed suicide after his roommate recorded and then released a video of him having sex with another man.  The video went viral among Rutger’s University students and Clementi then jumped off the George Washington Bridge.

The case became a national sensation and has had a national impact, forcing administrators to take bullying and LGBT issues more seriously.

Here is how NJ.com reported the overturning of the bias conviction:

NEWARK — Former Rutgers student Dharun Ravi has won his appeal seeking to overturn his convictions in the Tyler Clementi webcam case.

The appellate court sided with Ravi’s attorneys who had argued he never should have been charged with bias crimes and his convictions should be reversed. The court also ordered a new trial saying Ravi could not have received a fair trial as the bias evidence “permeated the trial.” 

“It’s far from over,” Ravi’s attorney Steven Altman said Friday morning. “I’m extraordinarily pleased with the decision. I haven’t spoken with the Ravi family yet, but I can only imagine they’re pleased as well.” 

The appellate decision arrives four years after Ravi’s conviction on several counts of bias intimidation and other charges following a highly publicized trial in New Brunswick, which put a national spotlight on cyber bullying.

Clementi, of Ridgewood, who was Ravi’s dorm mate at Rutgers University when the two were freshmen, jumped off the George Washington Bridge several days after the bullying incidents in September 2010 in which Ravi set up a remote webcam that spied on Clementi while he was having an intimate encounter with another man.

Ravi was not charged in Clementi’s death and his defense maintained the webcam incidents had nothing to do with Clementi’s decision to commit suicide. He was sentenced — and has already served — his 30-day sentence, three years of probation and 300 hours of community service.

After Ravi’s conviction in 2012, the state Supreme Court in a separate case struck down part of the state’s bias crime statute that focused on the victim’s state of mind. According to that case, it is the defendant’s state of mind and intent that is important, not the victim’s.

Dharun Ravi’s lawyers will try to reverse his convictions in the Tyler Clementi webcam case today in an appeals court.

The appellate court said the prosecution conceded in its oral arguments four of Ravi’s bias convictions should “be void as a matter of law,” and, accordingly, dismissed those charges with prejudice. The court also dismissed Ravi’s conviction on hindering his own apprehension and tampering with witnesses.

Altman previously said the Supreme Court’s decision on the anti-bias statute directly strikes down one of Ravi’s convictions and also brought into question decisions made by the trial judge, Superior Court Judge Glenn Berman, who is now retired. Berman permitted the prosecution to produce evidence of Tyler Clementi’s state of mind to the jury.

“The State used evidence revealing the victim’s reserved demeanor and expressions of shame and humiliation as a counterweight to defendant’s cavalier indifference and unabashed insensitivity to his roommate’s right to privacy and dignity,” the appellate court said in its ruling. “The prosecutor aggressively pressed this point to the jury in her eloquent closing argument.”

It continued: “It is unreasonable to expect a rational juror to remain unaffected by this evidence.”

The court also rejected the prosecution’s argument that Ravi should have received a stiffer sentence. 

Altman said the prosecution now has 20 days to decide whether or not to appeal to the state Supreme Court. Depending on what the prosecution decides, he said, it will then be a matter of whether “we can work something out in a mutually acceptable way.”

Messages placed to the Clementi family and the Middlesex County Prosecutor’s Office Friday have not yet been returned.”

Related Posts

Pasadena Reproductive Center Facing Lawsuit for Wrong Implantation

November 23, 2022

November 23, 2022

By Susan Payne A gay couple’s lawsuit against a reproductive center in Pasadena has been trimmed by a Los Angeles...

Los Angeles LGBT Center Honors Transgender Day of Remembrance, Mourns Colorado Shooting Victims

November 23, 2022

November 23, 2022

On the evening of November 21st, the Los Angeles LGBT Center held a candlelight vigil to honor Transgender Day of...

California to Send First Openly Gay Immigrant to Congress

November 23, 2022

November 23, 2022

By Susan Payne Long Beach voters ushered in two historical election firsts for the region during this year’s election.  Robert...

Phoebe Bridgers Covers Holiday Version of ‘So Much Wine’ Benefiting Los Angeles LGBT Center

November 22, 2022

November 22, 2022

By Susan Payne Singer-songwriter Phoebe Bridgers released a cover of the Handsome Family’s song “So Much Wine” from 2000. This...

Los Angeles LGBT Center Brings Together LGBTQ+ Seniors and Youth for First Intergenerational Thanksgiving Celebration

November 18, 2022

November 18, 2022

Three years after the grand opening of the Anita May Rosenstein Campus, the Los Angeles LGBT Center will celebrate the...

Palm Springs Pride Parade ‘Say Gay’ Draws Large Crowd

November 18, 2022

November 18, 2022

By Susan Payne The 36th annual Greater Palm Springs Pride Parade this month drew a large crowd and highlighted the...

LGBTQ Seniors Show Off Talents During Fall Showcase

November 18, 2022

November 18, 2022

By Susan Payne The Los Angeles LGBT Center held a fall showcase for senior citizens, the first of its kind...

North Hollywood Iliad Bookshop Set on Fire

November 18, 2022

November 18, 2022

By Susan Payne A 35-year-old bookstore was set on fire in North Hollywood in November and is believed to be...

LGBTQ Movie ‘Bros’ Flopped, but Still Important for Representation

November 10, 2022

November 10, 2022

By Susan Payne “Bros” features an all-LGBTQ principal cast in a big-studio romantic comedy among challenging political times for the...

Monkeypox Vaccine, Treatment Found to Slow Down Virus

November 10, 2022

November 10, 2022

By Susan Payne Monkeypox vaccines and treatments have been found to protect against further spread, according to the Los Angeles...

Trixie Mattel and Hundreds of LGBTQ+ Youth Celebrate the 30th Annual Models of Pride

November 10, 2022

November 10, 2022

Event presented by Glamazon L.A.—Amazon’s LGBTQ+ Affinity Group Presented by Glamazon L.A.—Amazon’s LGBTQ+ Affinity Group, the 30th anniversary Models of...

Newsom’s Bill Protects Transgender Young and Families Fleeing Red-State Policies

November 1, 2022

November 1, 2022

By Susan Payne Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a bill into law that aims to protect transgender youth and families fleeing...

Long Beach Wants Your Feedback on the New LGBTQ+ Cultural District

November 1, 2022

November 1, 2022

By Susan Payne Long Beach’s LGBTQ history will soon be memorialized by the city with its new LGBTQ Cultural District. ...

LA Strippers Win Approval to Unionize

October 21, 2022

October 21, 2022

By Susan Payne  An official from the National Labor Relations Board gave strippers at a Los Angeles club approval to...