April 17, 2021 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

Hurdle for Marriage Equality in Puerto Rico

Puerto Rican Federal Judge Stands Up to Gay Marriage
Puerto Rican Federal Judge Stands Up to Gay Marriage

BY ANGELO CASIANO  |  3/10/2016  |  UPDATE: Puerto Rico’s Governor Alejandro García Padilla has instructed government entities to continue issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples and recognizing such marriages performed out-of-state


A United States District Court judge in Puerto Rico, Juan M. Pérez-Giménez, has just issued an order stating that the Supreme Court ruling that made same-sex marriage a constitutional right does not automatically apply to the island territory.

In a 10-page document, Perez-Gimenez denied the resources requested by the human rights defender and lawyer Ada Conde Vidal along with other plaintiffs almost two years ago against the constitutionality of Article 68 of the Civil Code of Puerto Rico that defines marriage as a civil institution between a man and a woman.

Perez-Gimemez said that the Obergefell v. Hodges ruling “does not incorporate the fundamental right in question to Puerto Rico through the Fourteenth Amendment (equal protection under the laws”) nor does it invalidate Article 68 (which defines marriage in the Civil Code of Puerto Rico)”.

The judge followed by saying that, “[i]t is not within the jurisdiction of this court to declare, as the parties request that the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees the right to marriage for same-sex.”

Perez-Gimenez states that the Fourteenth Amendment, unlike the states, does not automatically apply to citizens of Puerto Rico since it was not precisely extended by the Supreme Court ruling in question. The judge says that a right to same-sex marriage in Puerto Rico requires further clarifying language from the Supreme Court of the United States, or the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico or by legislation from the US Congress in the exercise of the powers conferred under the territorial clause to overturn Puerto Rico law and amend or repeal Article 68.

“One would be tempted to assume that the constant reference to the “states” in the case Obergefell includes the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. However, it is not the function of this court to venture into such an interpretation,” says the judge in his decision.

“For these reasons, the Court concludes that the fundamental right to marry, as has been recognized by the Supreme Court in Obergefell, has not been incorporated into the legal reality of Puerto Rico,” he concludes.

Thus, the judge denied the plaintiffs’ request to rule that the ban against marriage for same-sex codified in Article 68 of Puerto Rico’s Civil Code is a constitutional violation.

It is important to note that the ruling also covers, and thus, denies, the plaintiffs’ second argument to the effect that refusing to recognize the marriages performed in other jurisdictions was a constitutional violation.

Pérez-Gimenez’s decision comes at a critical time.

The United States Supreme Court is poised to decide a pair of cases that will conclusively tell us how Puerto Rico’s status as an unincorporated U.S. territory shall be interpreted when allocating constitutional rights.

One of the cases deals with bankruptcy laws while the second (and most important one), Pueblo v. Sánchez seeks to clarify the reach of the Fifth Amendment’s Double Jeopardy clause.

Scalia’s position during oral arguments in Pueblo v. Sánchez were in favor of applying the Double Jeopardy clause. His position in that case would credit the notion that Puerto Rico is an unincorporated territory, which would in turn support the basis for Pérez-Gimenez’s decision not to automatically apply marriage equality to the Island.

Justice Scalia heard this case prior to his passing and almost certainly left his views in writing before his untimely death. The Plaintiffs in the case against Article 68 immediately vowed to return to Boston’s Court of Appeals for the First Circuit hoping for a summary reversal of tonight’s unfortunate and unexpected decision by Pérez-Gimenez.

Related Posts

Edify TV: Helping Local Cultural, Religious and LGBTQ+ Centers

April 11, 2021

April 11, 2021

Westside cultural, religious and LGBTQ+ centers stand to benefit from a new fund the City of Los Angeles has created...

Lil Nas X “Satan Shoes” Controversy

April 9, 2021

April 9, 2021

Since releasing his controversially queer-positive music video “Montero (Call Me By Your Name)” gay singer/rapper Lil Nas X has had...

L.A. Stage Alliance To Cease Operations After Several Companies Exit

April 9, 2021

April 9, 2021

The Los Angeles Stage Alliance (LASA) announced that it would “cease all operations” following the departure of more than 25...

Gender Neutral Potato Head- E.P.I.C Pride Show, April 7th, 2021

April 6, 2021

April 6, 2021

E.P.I.C Pride, Highlighting the latest LGBTQ news in Entertainment, Politics, International affairs, and Culture.  – Gender Neutral Potato Head  –...

James Charles Admits Messaging 16 Year Old Boys

April 4, 2021

April 4, 2021

YouTube star, makeup artist and Los Angeles resident James Charles issued an apology video entitled “Holding Myself Accountable” admitting to...

Tina Turner Documentary Breaks Records

April 4, 2021

April 4, 2021

Singer, song writer and gay icon Tina Turner released a documentary on HBO Max as a farewell to her fans...

Trans Visibility Day Proclamation From President Biden

April 1, 2021

April 1, 2021

Yesterday marked the 12th anniversary of Trans Visibility Day and the first time a sitting president has ever made a...

Pride Poets’ Corner: Double Dutch Nymph By Féi Hernandez

March 28, 2021

March 28, 2021

The Pride LA and West Hollywood Poet Laureate Brian Sonia-Wallace would like to introduce Féi Hernandez featuring their latest work...

Los Angeles Becomes First No-Kill City For Animal Shelters

March 28, 2021

March 28, 2021

The City of Los Angeles has become a no-kill city for animal shelters for the first time, thanks to the...

Bisexual Men Have Higher Chance Of Developing Eating Disorders

March 28, 2021

March 28, 2021

March is Bisexual Health Awareness Month and according to a study done by the University of California San Francisco bisexual...

First Gay Teen Captain America Revealed By Marvel

March 28, 2021

March 28, 2021

Marvel Comics has revealed the first look at a new Captain America who happens to be a gay teen.  The...

Candlelit Vigil Held For Rayanna Pardo

March 25, 2021

March 25, 2021

A candlelit vigil was held on March 20th for Rayanna Pardo, a trans woman of color who died three days...

32nd Annual GLAAD Media Awards

March 21, 2021

March 21, 2021

GLAAD, the world’s largest lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ) media advocacy organization, today announced a new slate of...

Miss Great Britain Comes Out As Bisexual – E.P.I.C Pride Show, March 17th, 2021

March 17, 2021

March 17, 2021

E.P.I.C Pride, Highlighting the latest LGBTQ news in Entertainment, Politics, International affairs, and Culture. ⁃ Miss Great Britain Is Bisexual...

New Harry Potter Video Game Will Feature Trans Witches & Wizards

March 14, 2021

March 14, 2021

The newest Harry Potter video game titled Hogwarts Legacy will allow players to create trans characters.  The game will allow...