February 24, 2020 The Newspaper Serving LGBT Los Angeles

L.A. resident seeks $10 million in 2013 SF Pride shooting

Trevor Gardner, 25, of Los Angeles. Facebook.
Trevor Gardner, 25, of Los Angeles. Facebook.

BY STEH HEMMELGARN  |  Organizers of San Francisco’s LGBT Pride celebration, who are being sued by a gay man who was shot at the 2013 festival, are headed to trial after last-minute settlement talks collapsed Tuesday.

Trevor Gardner, 25, of Los Angeles, filed his lawsuit in 2014 claiming that lax security was to blame for the incident, in which he was shot in the leg.

Much of the trial, which is expected to start next week and which Gardner’s attorney has estimated will take five weeks, is set to involve exactly what San Francisco LGBT Pride Celebration Committee officials could realistically do to boost security. Discussion will likely include metal detectors, which SF Pride doesn’t currently employ.

In an October 1 declaration, Forrest Franklin, whom SF Pride has designated as an expert witness on security in the case, pointed to differences between the San Francisco and Los Angeles Pride festivals and sought to explain why certain security measures would be impractical at the Bay Area event.

At the Los Angeles party, attendees “allegedly” have to go through metal detectors, he said.

San Francisco’s Pride is “many times larger than any other similar event, including the Los Angeles Pride event,” Franklin said, and it’s “held within a large footprint of the city, covering many city blocks,” while the Los Angeles festival “is held within a single site.”

The San Francisco celebration footprint “encompasses numerous privately-owned properties, including commercial properties, parking garages, long-term hotels, and other properties in which individuals would likely to be present irrespective of the occurrences of any San Francisco Pride event.”

In documents filed Tuesday, Maria Caruana, Pride’s attorney, made similar comments.

Los Angeles’ Pride event, “is fundamentally different” from San Francisco’s festival, Caruana said.

Among other issues, LA Pride “occurs inside an enclosed park,” while San Francisco’s celebration “includes a parade and occurs in a 7 x 4 city block area.”

The Los Angeles event has at most drawn 90,000 people in recent years, while at least 500,000 come to San Francisco’s Pride, Caruana said, citing a witness deposition.

Franklin talked more about metal detectors in his declaration.

“Metal detectors and similar perimeter security measures are no guarantee against the presence of weapons,” he said.

“In addition,” Franklin said, “simple math extrapolation supports the premise that screening the hundreds of thousands of persons expected under the permit language would require several nonstop 24-hour days to process, assuming all gates were equipped [and] staffed … .”

He also said the shooting, in which no arrests have been reported, “is consistent with gang violence,” and those “incidents are extremely difficult to control.”

Gardner alleges that after the shooting “he was left to bleed out,” Franklin said, but based on his evaluation of the incident, he said police “were on the scene within three minutes of the shooting. In fact, the first responder to the scene was then-San Francisco Police Deputy Chief John Loftus. … That one of the first responders was one of the highest ranking police personnel in the city is likewise an indication of the extent of the police presence” at the event.

Franklin also noted in his declaration that Gardner was shot at 6:35 p.m., minutes after the event had officially ended.

SF Pride “would not reasonably deploy crowd control measures to keep persons out of an event that had concluded,” he said.

In July, SF Pride filed a motion for summary judgment asking for the case to be decided without going to trial.

But in an order signed in October, Superior Court Judge Ernest H. Goldsmith denied SF Pride’s request, and suggested the organization should require metal detectors and check people’s bags, among other measures.

“The causal link between defendant’s security failures and plaintiff’s injury is robust,” Goldsmith wrote.

Gardner is expected to testify in the trial, as are SF Pride and police officials, witnesses to the shooting, Gardner’s doctors, and security experts.

Caruana has also sought to get police Chief Greg Suhr to testify in the case, according to the court documents, but the city has rebuffed that effort.

Gardner, who was accompanied in court by his parents, declined to comment on the case. SF Pride Executive Director George Ridgely, who was also in court, declined to comment, as well.

Eric Ryan, who was also shot in the 2013 incident at Pride, has also filed a lawsuit against SF Pride.

In his 2014 complaint, Gardner said he was seeking “not less than $10 million.”

Seth Hemmelgarn is an an assistant editor at the Bay Area Reporter, the LGBT newspaper in San Francisco.

Related Posts

Upcoming HBO Series About Drag Shows

February 21, 2020

February 21, 2020

“We’re Here” Debuts this spring By Staff Writer Learn more about a new HBO series debuting this spring that revolves...

New Pride Festival for Los Angeles Area

February 21, 2020

February 21, 2020

By Staff Writer A new Pride festival is coming to the Los Angeles area this May. This year, for the...

Transgender Care Services Coming to Baldwin Park

February 18, 2020

February 18, 2020

By Staff Writer A new Planned Parenthood center opening soon in Baldwin Park will provide transgender care services to a...

Texas Files Suit Against California’s Travel Ban to State

February 18, 2020

February 18, 2020

Texas asks U.S. Supreme Court to overturn California’s travel ban to Texas By Sam Catanzaro Texas is asking the U.S....

WeHo Opens Nominations For 2020 Rainbow Key Awards

February 18, 2020

February 18, 2020

Nominations will be Accepted Until Thursday, February 27 By Staff Writer The City of West Hollywood is gathering nominations for...

News Brief: Calls for LGBTQ CA Supreme Court Judge

February 14, 2020

February 14, 2020

Sen. Scott Winer and Assemblymember Todd Gloria introduce send letter to Gov. Gavin Newsom By Kerry Slater Two prominent state...

Addressing LA’s Increase in Syphilis

February 14, 2020

February 14, 2020

Legislation introduced to allow expanded rapid testing By Chole Marie Rivera February 4, Senator Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco) introduced legislation...

Cirque Du Soleil Presents Equality Night at Dodger Stadium

February 12, 2020

February 12, 2020

Proceeds benefiting Los Angeles LGBT Center By Chole Marie Rivera On Thursday, February 13 Cirque Du Soleil hosted Equality Night,...

Edify TV: LGBTQIA+ Health Conference

February 11, 2020

February 11, 2020

Learn more about the annual Southern California LGBTQIA+ Health Conference that was held last weekend at the David Geffen School of...

LGBTQ+ Representation in the Entertainment Industry

February 11, 2020

February 11, 2020

Continuing its commitment to lead the push for diversity, equality and inclusion of quality LGBTQ+ content in entertainment, ClexaCon is...

City of WeHo Commits More Funds Toward LA Pride

February 10, 2020

February 10, 2020

By Chole Rivera The 50th Annual L.A. Pride is on the horizon and the City of West Hollywood recently took...

Man Charged for Series of LGTBQ Attacks in Culver City

February 7, 2020

February 7, 2020

Joshua Immanuel Ebow charged for Culver City and West Los Angeles attacks By Sam Catanzaro A former delivery driver has...

Honoring National Black HIV/AIDS Awareness Day at the ONE Archive

February 4, 2020

February 4, 2020

National Black HIV/AIDS Awareness Day is on Friday, February 7. In the LGBTQ+ community, HIV/AIDS disproportionately affects gay black men...

LGBT Center to Host Groundbreaking Conference for LGBT Widows and Widowers in L.A.

January 30, 2020

January 30, 2020

Renowned Designer, Author, Advocate Nate Berkus to Give Keynote Address On Saturday, February 29, the Los Angeles LGBT Center will host...